Rossa White has witnessed the Irish economy from the outside in and the inside out. 

As chief economist of Davy during the days of boom and bust, White analysed the economy through the lens of the financial markets. 

As the troika landed in Ireland, he pivoted to the NTMA, where he was part of the team that re-engaged with investors and helped smooth out Ireland’s return to the bond market. 

He then spent five years at DCC, witnessing firsthand the challenges and opportunities facing the economy from inside a major Irish conglomerate.

His latest role is as chief economist with EY, weaving together the strands of his career to date – government, markets, and industry – for the professional services firm.

That breadth of experience gives White a valuable perspective on the state of the Irish economy today. In his assessment, the numbers point to an economy in “excellent shape” – and better equipped to withstand a major shock than at any point since he began covering the beat at the turn of the century.

He points to some of the headline numbers from the Economic Eye report, which he has just authored for his new employer EY. 

The domestic economy, measured by modified domestic demand, is forecast to grow by 3.5% this year and 3% in 2027 – more than double the eurozone average, White points out. 

Employment is expected to increase by around 1% next year, with unemployment averaging 5.1%, only marginally above this year’s estimated 4.9%. The Government, meanwhile, continues to be one of only three countries in the Euro Area to run a budget surplus.

“We are the envy of much of Europe,” White says, pointing to the strength of the balance sheet of the State, the banks and of households. 

“There is a big cushion for a shock,” he says, adding that the US, one of the key drivers of Ireland’s economic prosperity, also has a similar buffer.

Amid the positive data, White accepts that many people feel they are not overly benefiting from the bounty. Some of this disconnect relates to the impact of inflation (although he adds that wage inflation is helping to mitigate this), but much also comes from the emergence of what the report describes as a “two-speed economy”. 

One, powered by technology and manufacturing, is growing strongly. Other sectors – distribution, transport, retail, and hospitality – are not.

The numbers in the EY report are striking. 

Technology output has doubled since the beginning of the decade, and the sector is now responsible for a share of economic output four times greater than its share of employment. Its contribution to the tax take has grown even faster than its output since just before Covid.

Manufacturing remains the biggest output sector, but White explains that technology has become the more powerful engine of recent growth. 

The contrast with parts of the domestic economy is stark. Distribution, transport, retail, and hospitality account for more than 20% of employment but generate only about half that proportion of output. Their production has been virtually unchanged this decade.

“This helps explain what a lot of people are feeling,” he says.

As the report puts it: “Add in slowish growth in commercial construction and the spectre of a two-speed economy is clear.”

There are obvious reasons why the technology sector is performing so strongly. Ireland is benefiting from the extraordinary investment being made by the world’s biggest technology companies as they compete to build the infrastructure needed to support AI.

A separate analysis in Ibec’s latest economic outlook, published last week, illustrates just how quickly the global AI investment boom is feeding into the Irish economy.

Capital investment in information and communications technology has risen to almost 2.5% of national income, from just 1% two years ago. It now represents one euro in every 10 invested domestically.

The value of Ireland’s annualised trade in AI-related goods, including semiconductors, has more than doubled in two years. Ireland accounts for around 18% of European semiconductor exports, although its share of the global market remains relatively small at about 1%.

A separate analysis by Goodbody estimates that AI and data-centre capital investment accounted for around 20% of the increase in domestic demand over the past year, underlining how directly the investment boom is feeding into Ireland’s growth figures.

Meanwhile, in another report (yes, another one), the Central Bank warned on Thursday that an “acute” risk of a slump in AI stocks poses a threat to multinational tech investment and tax revenue in the Republic.

(For a thought-provoking analysis on the potential harm of AI to the economy, read Constantin’s column from Thursday.)

For Ireland, the stakes are high. The country is benefiting from the investment boom through trade, capital expenditure, employment and tax receipts. But it has little control over the investment decisions being made by a relatively small number of American technology companies, or the appetite of global investors to keep funding them.

Nor is the infrastructure required to accommodate that investment guaranteed to be available. Goodbody warns that power availability, grid congestion, and connection timelines are increasingly constraining further data-centre development.

This broader theme – of overreliance – was touched upon in a country report by the European Commission, also published in recent days, when it said Ireland’s concentration of economic activity in a small number of multinational-dominated sectors leaves it exposed to company-specific shocks and adverse international developments.

That vulnerability also extends to the public finances. The State is forecast to run a surplus of 1.4% of GDP this year and next, but the Commission highlights the continued risks arising from the concentration of corporation tax receipts.

It expects an additional €3 billion in top-up tax receipts in 2027, but says around half of that increase will unwind in 2028, partly because of the timing of tax returns.

The message is not that the Irish economy is in trouble. Rather, it is that the strength of the domestic economy, the volatility of the multinational sector, and the health of the public finances are three different things. They do not always move in the same direction.

This is where White’s assessment provides an important counterpoint to some of the more cautionary analysis. Ireland’s dependence on the US technology sector and the investment decisions of a relatively small number of multinational companies is a genuine vulnerability.

But the country is also in a much stronger financial position to absorb a reversal than it was during the last major economic downturn.

Elsewhere last week…

We have a Black Friday offer for new members that could make an ideal Christmas present. For €200, you get a year of The Currency, unlimited access to The Wall Street Journal, and a free Samsonite Upscape Spinner suitcase worth €235. In other words, the suitcase alone is worth more than the price of the subscription. It’s a quality deal, whether you’re giving it or getting it. If you know someone who would enjoy becoming a Currency reader, or fancy treating yourself, you can find all the details here.

Last week, The Currency received six nominations for this year’s UCD Smurfit School Business Journalist Awards, more than any other media organisation. Alice Chambers, Hannah McCarthy, Niall Sargent, Francesca Comyn, and Thomas Hubert all received nominations for their work over the past year. The winner of each category will be announced at an awards ceremony on Wednesday, December 16. The winner of the Outstanding Achievement Award will be announced at the event. 

Meanwhile, Tom caught up with Nick Corocoran, the co-founder of Cardinal Capital Group, who asked why Irish pension funds invest much less outside listed equities than their international peers.

He also spoke with Derek Walpole, the chief investment officer of wealth manager Biograph. He explained its approach, how it wants to grow, and his journey from astrophysics to investment.

The company behind Tinder is battling Ireland’s Data Protection Commission. From distributing the dating app across Europe to managing user data and holding international investments, analysis by The Currency reveals that Ireland has a much bigger role in the group than their modest headcount suggests.